Rogerian Argument (Rough Draft) (SO Rough) (Don’t cut yourself on the roughness) #9

Many people in the recent years have been turning over a new leaf by becoming vegetarians and vegans. By exempting meat and other animal-related products from their diet, these people are living healthy lives like trying to make an impact on the earth, and most importantly to cause less harm to animals. It goes to say that this is a very hard but fulfilling way to live life, and to further their beliefs they have begun to feed their omnivorous and carnivorous pets vegan and vegetarian foods. While it may seem difficult it is certainly possible to switch a dog and cats diet to a more vegan and vegetarian friendly kind while still keeping them extremely, if not more healthy than they would be while eating regular commercial kibbles and wet foods. This has been going on for years, but only the past few years have been brought into the public eye.

It is amazing what we can do these days to help the environment and the animals that habit this earth. With vegan and vegetarian dog and cat foods, people are able to keep their pets healthier than before with the added nutrition that fruits, vegetables and vitamins provide. It is also a great way to prevent these animals from eating a lot of the ‘junk’ meat that commercial dog and cat foods add. Certainly the label can say chicken, but when looked further into, it is shown that a lot of the meat used is mostly consisting of intestines, organs, and any other leftover meat that can be ground up– not the lean kind we monitor so closely. This is important, as the ‘junk’ meat in commercial foods can often cause allergy symptoms, indigestion, and other kinds of sickness in both dogs and cats.

All in all, whether we feed our pets Blue Buffalo or  V-dog, we just want them to be happy, healthy, and live the longest lives that they can. It goes to say that one of the longest living dogs known (living to 28) was also on a vegetarian diet (http://www.care2.com/greenliving/vegetarian-dog-lives-to-189-years.html). Perhaps it is time that we can all change our pets food to something healthier and vegetable-based. We could save the lives of so many animals by switching their diets; both in the farms and in our homes, all by switching to a different pet food. It sounds easy, almost too easy, and unfortunately just like all other foods we feed our pets, there will  be to the potential consequences that these healthy foods will  cause our beloved companions.

Vegetarian and Vegan dog foods are amazing– they help dogs immensely with health, let them live longer and healthier lives, as well as preventing them from eating ‘junk’ meat often seen in commercial foods. To make it even easier, there are even companies that now produce kibble and wet food for dogs AND cats that are certified to fulfill all of their nutritional needs, so you won’t even have to toss a salad. However while dogs are omnivorous, they also have lesser diet and nutritional needs than cats do, simply because of the way their body synthesizes different proteins and sunlight (http://pets.webmd.com/features/vegetarian-diet-dogs-cats). Due to this, while a vegan or vegetarian diet may be possible for a dog, it is highly recommended that cats, a carnivorous species, should not be fed a completely vegetarian cat food. While it is possible to feed them a meat free diet, this constitutes the use of many vitamins for the loss of vitamins A and D, as well as a substitute for taurine creation. Without these, a cat can easily get sick and die to to malnutrition– something that nobody wants.

So what should happen? Do we keep feeding our pets foods with or without meats? The answer is both. While cats can be provided with substitutes, it is best for them to get their nutrients straight from the source. This of it like this, humans are better off getting vitamins and minerals from fruits and veggies and the like, rather than through multivitamins– so shouldn’t your pet be the same? While cats are no recommended for vegan and vegetarian diets, dogs are perfectly fine with the switch, as their bodies are able to produce vitamins A and D, as well as taurine, without the aid of meat. If pet owners are truly set on feeding their companions strict, meat free diets, they should consider getting a vegetarian or vegan animal, such as hamsters, gerbils and types of birds, as well as other species. Finally, vegan and vegetarian pet food can be very pricey and is not usually sold in grocery or pet stores, so one must consider the added cost of very expensive food into their plan.


http://pets.webmd.com/features/vegetarian-diet-dogs-cats

http://www.peta.org/living/companion-animals/vegetarian-cats-dogs/

http://v-dog.com/

http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/AmazingAnimals/story?id=7154396&page=1

http://www.care2.com/greenliving/vegetarian-dog-lives-to-189-years.html

Advertisements

One thought on “Rogerian Argument (Rough Draft) (SO Rough) (Don’t cut yourself on the roughness) #9

  1. I loved your paper! i switched my dog to a more veggie based food awhile back and he loves it. Now for your paper 😀 I liked how to connected humans to cats and dogs. You started off saying the humans have gone to eating more veggies and fruits and you think pets can to. Your intro was strong, it grabbed me and wanted me to keep reading. If anything could be added it would have to be, why is it so important to switch. But even that might be to easy, as i am grasping at straws for something. I think your argument has good use of Kiros. The timing of this argument is great, people are switching to a more leafy diet and there is tons of research and opinions on the eating style change, why not pass the change onto our pets to make them healthier! I think by having this argument for pets at the same time that we are having it for humans is smart. I see the common ground in this paper being that we need to have a better balance between meats and veggies, and move towards a more veggie based pet food. I do pose that you add to your common ground of we wants our pets as healthy as they can be. You brought in good sources and even brought in research that helped your case. I have nothing to add to the sources other than more is better. In the paper i guessed you were on the side for more veggies, you put tons of work into building your argument, i would of liked to seen more of the oppositions arguments. Your launguage was really neutral other than when you came out to say what you thought, and it was really well structured from what i saw. Your personal expressions were in the right places and did not overpower what the argument was about, great job again (three gold stars for you). You leave the conclusion open ended which i like. You pose a possible way to make everyone happy but leave it up to us to decide what should happen. Good passive writing again. I would liked to see more than one way to end your paper, did you think of other ways to reach common ground? Things like that are always good to think about. Great paper, can’t wait to see what you come up with for the final draft 😀

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s